- A good reply rate for cold LinkedIn outreach is well above 13%. In our study of senior professional and financial services outreach, 13.4% of 942 cold conversations got a reply. Leave out one company announcement sent to 527 people and the other 415 cold messages replied at about 25%. Warm conversations replied at 57.4%.
- Reply rate is not the number that pays. Two campaigns that replied at 13.3% and 35.9% both reached about 9 meeting conversations per 100 messages sent.
- What moved cold replies in our data: one specific observation about the person, exactly one question, 650 to 800 characters, and one short follow-up after 3 to 5 days.
- Judge your outreach on the replies that reach meeting intent, then on meetings held.
What is a good reply rate for cold LinkedIn outreach?
In our data, about 13% is the average and about 25% is good. Of 942 cold conversations that had been live for at least seven days, 13.4% got a reply.
That average hides a split. One company announcement went to 527 people and replied at 4.6%. The other 415 cold messages replied at about 25%. One mass message pulled the whole number down.
So read your own figure against both. Near 13% is the average for this kind of outreach. Nearer 25% is what the rest of the cold messages in our data did.
Warm outreach is a different game. Conversations that began warm replied at 57.4% (n=141), about four times the cold rate. Never judge a cold campaign against a warm number, or the other way round.
The figures come from The 2,279 LinkedIn DM Study: conversations started by senior people at professional and financial services firms across Africa, Europe and the Middle East. Every reply was read and classified by a person, not a sentiment model. It is observational data from our own client programmes, not a controlled experiment.
Why is reply rate the wrong number to stop at?
Because a higher reply rate did not mean more meetings. A fiduciary services campaign into a new European market replied at 13.3%, and 8 of its 11 replies (72.7%) reached meeting intent. A trade credit insurance campaign replied at 35.9%, and 26% of its replies did.
Per 100 messages sent, both reached about 9 meeting conversations (n=83 and n=66). Nearly three times the reply rate, the same meetings.
So count the replies that reach meeting intent, then the meetings held. We wrote more about this in the LinkedIn messages that get replies aren't the ones that get meetings, and about what each lane is for in warm vs cold LinkedIn outreach.
What raises a cold LinkedIn reply rate?
Four things stood out in the study.
- Be specific, not personal. Messages personalised with the name only replied at 10.7% (n=460). Adding a company or role reference moved it to 15.5% (n=458). One specific, verifiable observation about the person took it to 25% (n=24, directional).
- Ask exactly one question. Messages with no question replied at 9.5% (n=693). Messages with exactly one question replied at 23.8% (n=239). Two or more did no better than one (n=10, directional).
- Do not go too short. Cold messages under 350 characters engaged 7.1% of recipients (n=28). Messages of 650 to 800 characters engaged 15.6% (n=45), with no falloff below 800. A cold reader needs to know who you are, why them and why now. For warm conversations it flips: shorter wins.
- Follow up once, after 3 to 5 days. One follow-up sent 3 to 5 days after the first message revived 14.6% of silent threads (n=355). Waiting 6 to 9 days nearly halved that, to 8.2% (n=73). The follow-ups that worked were short, under 200 characters.
How should a firm judge its own numbers?
Run your figures the way the study did, or you will compare the wrong things.
- Count only conversations that have been live for at least seven days. Newer ones have not had time to reply.
- Split warm from cold. A warm list will flatter a cold campaign.
- Split mass sends from one-to-one messages. In our data one announcement to 527 people cut the cold average from about 25% to 13.4%.
- Then look at the share of replies that reach meeting intent, and the meetings held.
If referrals are still your main source of clients and LinkedIn is the second one you are building, our guide to winning clients beyond referrals shows where outreach fits.
Want to know what your own reply rate should be? We run a free 30-minute review of your profile, content and outreach, and tell you honestly what would move the needle for your firm.
Book a free LinkedIn review →Frequently asked questions
What is a good reply rate for cold LinkedIn outreach?
In our study, the average was 13.4% across 942 cold conversations started by senior people at professional and financial services firms. One mass announcement pulled that down; the other 415 cold messages replied at about 25%. So near 13% is average and nearer 25% is good. Warm conversations replied at 57.4%, so never compare the two.
Does a higher LinkedIn reply rate mean more meetings?
Not on its own. In our study, a campaign that replied at 13.3% and one that replied at 35.9% both reached about 9 meeting conversations per 100 messages sent, because far more of the lower campaign's replies reached meeting intent (72.7% against 26%). Judge outreach on the replies that reach meeting intent, then on meetings.
How long should a cold LinkedIn message be?
Longer than most advice suggests. In our study, cold messages under 350 characters engaged 7.1% of recipients (n=28), while messages of 650 to 800 characters engaged 15.6% (n=45), with no falloff below 800. A cold reader needs to know who you are, why them and why now. For warm messages, shorter wins.
When should you send a follow-up after a LinkedIn message gets no reply?
After 3 to 5 days. In our study, one follow-up sent 3 to 5 days after the first message revived 14.6% of silent threads (n=355), while waiting 6 to 9 days nearly halved that, to 8.2% (n=73). Keep the follow-up short, under 200 characters.
